Pokecheque wrote:
Yeah I think the ship has sailed on Matt Duchene being an elite player. I don't think he is, and I'm one of his biggest fans.
Unfortunately the Avs, I think, deep down inside, know this, but they're in save-face mode. They care more about the PR backlash when they trade one of the team's most popular players than they care about actual long-term value going forward.
But this is something. Patrick Roy is more or less being proven absolutely right when he publicly stated that he didn't think this core was good enough. But I think this is far, far more damning of the Avs' egregiously bad draft/development system than it is on the players themselves. This is what happens when your organization becomes far, far too insular and unable to even listen to outside voices.
That's half the problem though- do they really want to KEEP a guy who isn't elite but they're paying $6 million for 2 more years? This idea that they're going to restock completely with the return for him is insane. A lot of teams want him, but not at the crazy price Sakic wants. If it was anywhere near good value for another team, he'd be long gone already. Sakic is trying to save face, but he's looking out of touch. And having an unhappy fan favorite isn't going to play out well either.
I know Duchene isn't elite, but I think at this point he has a better chance of returning to
close-to-elite status in another jersey.